Out-of-Sample Test of Formula Investing Strategies

Can we simplify the complexities of the stock market and distill them into a simple set of quantifiable metrics? A lot of academic papers suggest this, and they offer formulas that should make the life of a stock picker easier. Some of the most compelling methodologies within this realm are the F-Score, Magic Formula, Acquirer’s Multiple, and the Conservative Formula. These quantitative strategies are designed to identify undervalued stocks with robust fundamentals and potential for high returns. But do they really work out-of-sample? A new paper by Marcel Schwartz and Matthias X. Hanauer tries to answer this interesting question…

Continue reading »

Top Ten Blog Posts on Quantpedia in 2024

The year 2024 is nearly behind us, so it’s an excellent time for a short recapitulation. In the previous 12 months, we have been busy again (as usual) and have published over 70 short analyses of academic papers and our own research articles. The end of the year is a good opportunity to summarize 10 of them, which were the most popular (based on the Google Analytics ranking). The top 10 is diverse, as usual; once again, we hope that you may find something you have not read yet …

Continue reading »

Design Choices in ML and the Cross-Section of Stock Returns

For those who have not yet had the chance to read it, we recommend the latest empirical study by Minghui Chen, Matthias X. Hanauer, and Tobias Kalsbach, which shows that design choices in machine learning models, such as feature selection and hyperparameter tuning, are crucial to improving portfolio performance. Non-standard errors in machine learning predictions can lead to substantial portfolio return variations, and authors are highlighting the importance of robust model evaluation techniques.

Continue reading »

Can We Use Active Share Measure as a Predictor?

Active Share is a popular metric used to gauge how actively managed a portfolio is compared to its benchmark, but its predictive power for fund performance is questionable. Our research suggests that high Active Share often reflects exposure to systematic equity factors rather than genuine stock-picking skill. Additionally, inaccuracies in benchmark selection can distort the metric’s insights, making it unreliable as a standalone measure. A more effective approach is to conduct a factor analysis of alpha to better understand a manager’s performance and true sources of over/underperformance.

Continue reading »

The Impact of Methodological Choices on Machine Learning Portfolios

Studies using machine learning techniques for return forecasting have shown considerable promise. However, as in empirical asset pricing, researchers face numerous decisions around sampling methods and model estimation. This raises an important question: how do these methodological choices impact the performance of ML-driven trading strategies? Recent research by Vaibhav, Vedprakash, and Varun demonstrates that even small decisions can significantly affect overall performance. It appears that in machine learning, the old adage also holds true: the devil is in the details.

Continue reading »

Short Sellers: Informed Liquidity Suppliers

Short sellers often have a bad reputation, seen as market disruptors who profit from declining prices. Yet, they play a crucial role in making markets more efficient by identifying overvalued assets and correcting mispricings. A recent study uncovers another surprising aspect of their behavior: rather than just demanding liquidity, the most informed short sellers actually provide it. Using transaction-level data, the research shows that these traders supply liquidity, especially on news days and when trading on known anomalies, challenging the conventional view of short sellers as merely aggressive market participants.

Continue reading »

Valuing Stocks With Earnings

Today, we will venture a little into the fundamental analysis corner, and we will give you a glimpse of an intriguing paper (Hillenbrand and McCarthy, 2024) that discusses the advantages of using ‘Street’ earnings over traditional GAAP earnings. The paper suggests that ‘Street’ earnings provide better valuation estimates and improved financial analysis. Is this a way how to improve the performance of the struggling equity value factor?

Continue reading »

The Expected Returns of Machine-Learning Strategies

Does the investment in sophisticated machine learning algorithm research and development pay off? It is an important question, especially in light of the increasing costs related to the R&D of such algorithms and the possibility of decreasing returns for some methods developed in the more distant past. A recent paper by Azevedo, Hoegner, and Velikov (2023) evaluates the expected returns of machine learning-based trading strategies by considering transaction costs, post-publication decay, and the current high liquidity environment. The obstacles are not low, but research suggests that despite high turnover rates, some machine learning strategies continue to yield positive net returns.

Continue reading »

Oh My! I Bought A Wrong Stock! – Investigation of Lead-Lag Effect in Easily-Mistyped Tickers

Our new study aims to investigate the lead-lag effect between prominent, widely recognized stocks and smaller, less-known stocks with similar ticker symbols (for example, TSLA / TLSA), a phenomenon that has received limited attention in financial literature. The motivation behind this exploration stems from the hypothesis that investors, especially retail investors, may inadvertently trade on less-known stocks due to ticker symbol confusion, thereby impacting their price movements in a manner that correlates with the leading stocks. By examining this potential misidentification effect, our research seeks to shed some light on this interesting factor.

Continue reading »

ESG Investing during Calm and Crisis Periods

Over the last decade, investing responsibly and deploying capital for “ethically” correct and sustainable growth has been quite a theme. We dedicated a few blogs to this theme and have a separate ESG category for trading strategies in our database. It is often easy to commit financial resources to noble ideas during liquidity abundance. However, how do these methodologies fare during crisis times, such as when the GFC (Global Financial Crisis) or COVID-19 hit? That’s the question that a new paper by Henk Berkman and Mihir Tirodkar tries to answer.

Continue reading »
QuantPedia
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.